SEO · 4 min read
Who do AI tools recommend to Mumbai businesses? We asked 180 times
Short answer
in 180 answers from ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity to Mumbai buyer questions, the tools named 627 different businesses, and they rarely agreed. Only 2% of names came up in all three tools on the same question. Where a tool showed its sources, Perplexity leaned on directories (54% of its sources), and JustDial alone appeared in 53 of its 100 answers. Answers also shifted between runs: on Perplexity, about a third of names came back the second time.
- The three tools rarely named the same businesses: 2% of names appeared in all three.
- Perplexity leaned on directories; ChatGPT and Gemini more on businesses' own websites.
- Answers changed between runs, so one check on one day tells you little.
- Directory listings, clear service pages and honest reviews fit what we saw.
Want this checked for your business? Get a free 30-min audit → or WhatsApp us.
So being on these lists is not one job. Each tool behaves differently, and a single check tells you little.
What we did
We wrote 50 questions the way a buyer types them, such as "Good physiotherapist in Malad for back pain?". They cover 10 local categories across Borivali, Kandivali, Malad, Andheri, Thane and Mumbai as a whole. Each question went into a fresh chat in the free version of each tool. We recorded the businesses named and the sources shown.
| Tool | Questions | Answers | Named a business | Showed any source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Perplexity | 50 | 100 | 98 | 99 |
| ChatGPT | 30 | 40 | 40 | 18 |
| Gemini | 30 | 40 | 40 | 25 |
Finding 1: the three tools rarely agree
On the 30 questions asked in all three tools, we saw 406 different names.
| Named by | Names | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Any one tool | 406 | 100% |
| Two or more tools | 79 | 19% |
| All three tools | 11 | 2% |
Being named by one tool says little about the other two.
Finding 2: sources differ a lot by tool
| Source type | Perplexity (377 sources) | ChatGPT (33) | Gemini (69) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Directories and review sites | 54% | 15% | 27% |
| A business's own website | 31% | 54% | 72% |
| Blogs and "best of" lists | 6% | 0% | 0% |
| Official sites (for example MahaRERA) | 4% | 6% | 0% |
| Google, named in the answer | 0% | 21% | 0% |
| Reddit, Quora, social | 1% | 3% | 0% |
Shares are rounded down, so columns may not add up to 100%. Read the ChatGPT and Gemini columns with care. Their counts are small, because many answers showed no source at all. Often ChatGPT showed star ratings and review counts without saying where they came from.
Finding 3: on Perplexity, the category changes the source
| Category | Sources | Top source type |
|---|---|---|
| Restaurants | 32 | Directories 100% |
| Dentists | 33 | Directories 69% |
| Salons | 29 | Directories 62% |
| Physiotherapists | 28 | Directories 60% |
| Digital marketing agencies | 42 | Directories 57% |
| Jewellers | 35 | Directories 54% |
| Coaching classes | 26 | Directories 50% |
| Real estate agents | 48 | Directories 50% |
| Interior designers | 54 | Own websites 53% |
| CA firms | 50 | Own websites 48% |
Restaurants depended entirely on listing and food sites. Interior designers and CA firms were the two categories where a firm's own website was the top source. In real estate, official sources made up 29%, mostly MahaRERA.
Finding 4: answers change from run to run
We asked some questions twice, in fresh chats, and counted the names that appeared both times.
| Tool | Names in both runs | Questions compared |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 70% | 10 |
| Perplexity | 37% | 29 |
| Gemini | 36% | 10 |
ChatGPT was the steadiest here, on a small set. Perplexity and Gemini kept about a third. One check on one day is not a reliable picture.
What this means for a local business
Nothing here proves why any business was named. The data shows where the tools looked, not how they decide. Still, these five steps fit what we saw:
- Fix your directory listings. Directories were Perplexity's biggest source. Check your name, address, phone and category on JustDial, Practo or whichever site leads your trade.
- Give your website one clear page per service and area. Own websites were a top source for ChatGPT and Gemini when they showed one.
- Keep your Google Business Profile complete. We did not measure profiles directly, so treat this as basic good practice. Our local SEO checklist for Borivali, Kandivali and Malad walks through it.
- Earn honest reviews over time. Many answers quoted ratings and review counts when explaining a choice.
- Check more than once, in more than one tool. Ask your own buyer question in all three tools, twice, each month. Want a second pair of eyes? Get a free audit.
These steps can improve your chances. No one can promise a place in an AI answer. To run your own check, read how to measure AI search visibility and how to get your business recommended by ChatGPT, or see our SEO, AEO and GEO service.
Method and limits
- When: all answers were collected on 6 November 2026, from one computer.
- How: an AI assistant typed each question into the normal chat page, one at a time, and recorded the answer.
- Accounts: ChatGPT and Gemini were free and signed out. Perplexity's first 13 questions were signed out. It then required a sign-in, so the rest used a free account, with a new thread each time.
- Size: we planned 3 runs of 50 questions per tool and cut it to save time. ChatGPT and Gemini got 30 questions, and 10 of those were asked twice.
- Not a random sample. We chose the questions ourselves. This shows a pattern in these 180 answers, not all of Mumbai.
- Answers were not captured in full. We read the first part of long answers, so some names are missing. Our capture also improved during the first Perplexity round, so the Perplexity stability figure uses only the 29 questions captured the same way both times.
- Names were matched by a simple rule, so a few matches may be off, and the agreement figures are approximate.
- Sources were sorted by us. Gemini showed site names rather than links, so we sorted those by name.
- Not measured: we did not check whether each named business has a Google Business Profile, a website or directory reviews. We also did not check whether the answers were accurate.
- Who ran this: Vansh Marketing, a Mumbai agency that sells SEO, AEO and GEO work, so we have an interest in this topic. Our own name appeared in 0 of the 180 answers.
We publish counts only. No business is ranked or criticised here.
Frequently asked questions
Which AI tool recommends the most local businesses?
In this study Perplexity named the most per answer, at 6.5 on average. ChatGPT named 5.4 and Gemini 5.0.
Do AI tools use JustDial?
Perplexity cited JustDial in 53 of its 100 answers here. ChatGPT named it in 1 of 40 answers and Gemini in 10 of 40, and both showed fewer sources overall.
Will the same question always give the same names?
No. Between two runs, ChatGPT kept 70% of names and Gemini and Perplexity kept about a third.